Close this search box.
We use cookies to deliver the best experience on our website. By using our website, you agree to use of cookies.  Learn more.

Hull and East Yorkshire’s Super Sandwiches

There’s plenty of reasons as to why the sandwich is such a popular and beloved choice of food, it offers affordability, taste, and the opportunity of eating on the go, making it perfect for pretty much any and every occasion. Establishments serving up sandwiches can be found on virtually every street corner in Britain, and thankfully Hull and East Yorkshire is no different in this respect.

The local area is stuffed with delicatessens, cafes and eateries boasting some amazing unmissable sandwiches, and so with this in mind, here is a guide to some of Hull and East Yorkshire’s super sandwiches!

Marla’s Sandwich Shop

53 Princes Ave, Hull HU5 3QY

Marla’s Sandwich Shop manages to crop up on virtually every one of our food based articles, and for good reason! The eatery, now firmly situated on Princes Avenue, has amassed an ever growing group of loyal local customers, gained through friendly staff, a comfortable eating area, and delicious food.

Although Marla’s specialise in all sorts of dishes, including hot and cold breakfasts, it’s their amazing sandwiches for which they are known best! Halloumi Classic, Chicken Romesco, and Tofu Bahn Mi (Vegan), are some of their best known sandwiches, all of which are available for £8.75-a price which is more than justified by the quality of the food and the service with which it is served.

Check out their Facebook page for further information >>

Flour & Feast

10 Humber St, Hull HU1 1TG

One of Humber Street’s most popular places to eat and drink, Flour & Feast is a charming and homely eatery whose good quality food and comfortable seating area makes it an unforgettable place to visit. Like Marla’s, Flour & Feast doesn’t just specialise in one thing. Although it prides itself on serving up artisanal bread, croissants, doughnuts, and of course sandwiches are also available to purchase!

Standout sandwiches include the Reuben, containing: pastrami, house pickled veggies and mustard mayo, as well as a personal favourite of mine, the broccoli banh mi – perfect for those seeking something healthy and delicious. For delicious sandwiches made using only the finest local ingredients, visit Flour & Feast.

Check out their website for further information >>


216 Newland Ave, Hull HU5 2ND

Barleys is undoubtedly one of the local area’s most popular vegan eateries and having been open a little over two years now, it seems that the establishment is still growing more popular and beloved every day. Situated on Newland Avenue, Barleys serves up everything from salads and sausage rolls to brownies and sandwiches – ensuring that there’s something delicious for everyone.

Some of the establishment’s best loved sandwiches are as follows: pesto grilled cheese, the muffuletta, and, perhaps one of their most popular dishes, the chick’n caesar – all of which you can have to take out or eat in! for delicious vegan sandwiches with a unique twist, Barleys is your only choice.

Check out their Facebook page for further information >>

Madison’s Deli

88 Newland Ave, Hull HU5 3AB

Madison’s is a popular local family owned deli situated on Newland Avenue. Serving up everything from cooked meats and sausage rolls to cakes and sandwiches, Madison’s prides itself on good quality food and affordability. They have an extensive and varied sandwich menu, including a handful of vegetarian and vegan options. Madison’s Deli is the perfect choice for those seeking a delicious, homemade sandwich at an affordable price.

Check out their Facebook page for further information >>

Taste 125

125 Newland Avenue, Hull HU5 2ES

Just across the road from Madison’s Deli is Taste 125, a charming delicatessen which, much like Madison’s, prides itself on good quality homemade food and affordability. Thanks to it’s charming interior and friendly staff, Taste 125 has also acquired a loyal band of local customers who swear by the establishments tasty comfort food. Those after a delicious rustic sandwich in a hurry can do no better than Taste 125!

Check out their Facebook page for further information >>


23-25 Carr Ln, Hull HU1 3RB

First established in 1984, Herby’s is a local, family run business which prides itself on first class sandwiches and catering. A mere stone’s throw away from Princes Quay, in the centre of Hull, Herby’s perfectly combines affordability and taste, and given the quality of their sandwiches, it’s no wonder that the establishment has flourished for so long.

Like Madison’s and Taste 125, Herby’s is a delicatessen of the traditional sort, it’s sandwich menu being both extensive and varied. Now serving up vegan and vegetarian options, Herby’s ensures that each and every customer is satisfied.

Check out their website for further information >>


245 Greenwood Ave, Hull HU16 9RY

Fletcher’s, a bakery, deli and sandwich shop found on Greenwood Avenue, is full of nothing but glowing reviews from customers and acclaim from the local area. Each and every one of their delicious sandwiches is made to order, and, in part thanks to their using only the finest local ingredients, their sandwiches are some of the best in Hull and East Yorkshire!

Sandwich choices vary from egg mayonnaise and beef to bacon and pulled pork, so whether you’re in the mood for a delicious hot breakfast sandwich, or something a little healthier, Fletcher’s is capable of serving up both at an affordable price! When it comes to finding great sandwiches, you need to listen to the voices of the locals, and none have their praise more so than Fletcher’s.

Check out their website for further information >>


Nibble @ The Dock, Queen St, Hull HU1 1UU

Less than a minute’s walk away from Flour & Feast is Nibble, another one of Humber Street’s popular and impressive eateries. Though formally known as a brunch restaurant, Nibble is also responsible for serving up some of the local area’s most decadent and delicious sandwiches – often with a twist.

There are plenty of sandwiches to choose from at Nibble currently, including: the meatball sub, the battered fish s’wich, grilled cheese special, and the veggie stack – all of which are made using only the best ingredients from local suppliers.

Nibble’s sandwiches are more expensive than those served at Madison’s, Fletcher’s and Herby’s, but this escalation in price is more than warranted by the taste of the product! Nibble’s sandwiches are perfect for those hankering after something indulgent and tasty after a long week at work.

Check out their Facebook page for further information >>

Benedict’s Sandwich Bar

42 Cottingham Rd, Hull HU6 7RA

Located on Cottingham Road, Benedict’s Sandwich Bar is something of a hidden gem in the local area. Combining the affordability and charm of Fletcher’s with Nibble’s decadence, Benedict’s is capable of doing it all.

Whether it’s something simple and wholesome you’re after, like a bacon sandwich, or something more adventurous like a buffalo chicken sandwich served with blue cheese dressing – Benedict’s have you covered. Next time you’re in need of a sandwich and want to try somewhere new, I recommend you give Benedict’s a visit, you won’t be disappointed!

Check out their Facebook page for further information >>

Thieving Harry’s

73 Humber St, Hull HU1 1UD

It’s a testament to Thieving Harry’s success how often they’ve been featured here on Hull What’s On. Found on the corner of Humber Street overlooking Hull’s picturesque Marina, Thieving Harry’s is an atmospheric and comfortable place to visit-no matter the day or occasion, formal or casual, you feel at home.

Although everything served up at Thieving Harry’s is made to the highest of standards, their delicious sandwiches are a particular highlight. In keeping with the areas cosmopolitan feel, the establishment has a number of vegan and vegetarian options available, of which their Tofu B.L.T is especially good! Other standout sandwiches include their classic grilled cheese and their locally famous ‘Harry’s B.L.T’.

Check out their website for further information >>

Mr Smith’s Delicatessen

129-131 Hallgate, Cottingham HU16 4DA

A personal favourite of mine, Mr Smith’s Delicatessen does everything an exceptional deli should do and more. Found in the centre of Cottingham near St. Mary’s Church, Mr Smith’s is an affordable and homely deli whose oldy-worldy exterior and friendly staff grants it some extra charm. Like Madison’s and Herby’s, Mr Smith’s champions good-quality, locally sourced ingredients and affordability, making it the perfect place to come when you’re in need of a wholesome snack!

Check out their Instagram page for further information >>

Harrison’s of Beverley

31 Saturday Market, Beverley HU17 8BE

Last but by no means least on today’s list is Harrison’s of Beverley, an impressive sandwich bar and eatery found in the heart of Beverley’s historic Saturday Market. Serving up freshly made pastries, ice cream, and a whole host of tasty sandwiches, Harrison’s is the sort of place that has something for everyone. Some of their most popular sandwiches are as follows: Harrison’s signature salt beef, marinated halloumi (vegetarian), steak & cheddar, and their signature lobster roll. Harrison’s does decadent sandwiches like no other!

Check out their Facebook page for further information >>

For more food and drinks guides in Hull & East Yorkshire click here >>

Hull news, events & special offers

Our weekly digest rounds up the best things happening around Hull & East Yorkshire.


Got something to share?

We want to share everything positive that’s going on around Hull. We have loads of great ways to share your stuff:
Click the button above or email us at
*Registration required
Featured Hull Events
Unmissable offers!
Places you should visit

Hull news, events & offers by email

Stay up to date on everything good happening locally!